Sign inStart free trial
← Resources

Xero Cashbook Alternatives: GST & Non-GST Accounting

Prosaic Team5 min read

Accountants managing straightforward compliance tasks for sole proprietors, rental properties, and trusts have traditionally relied on Xero Cashbook. As Xero phases out this product, accounting professionals are exploring alternative solutions to maintain workflow efficiency without transitioning to pricier options.

What is Xero Cashbook?

Xero Cashbook is a simplified accounting solution tailored for accountants overseeing clients with basic financial requirements. It delivers bank feed integration and transaction reconciliation capabilities without the extensive feature set of Xero's comprehensive offering.

Current pricing:

  • Non-GST Cashbook: $16/month per client
  • GST Cashbook: $28/month per client

However, Xero is retiring the GST Cashbook variant and introducing the new Ignite plan at $35/month — prompting accountants to evaluate viable alternatives.

Why Xero Cashbook gained popularity

The solution attracted accountants through its affordable approach to addressing straightforward client accounting needs. It offered simplified reconciliation and bank feed features without unnecessary complexity — particularly valuable for landlords and independent contractors needing uncomplicated compliance support.

Xero Cashbook alternatives

1. Spreadsheets and bank statements

Using Excel or Google Sheets with manual transaction recording offers a budget-conscious option for clients with minimal financial activity. While this approach eliminates automated bank feeds, it remains viable for very straightforward operations. However, higher transaction volumes increase error risks and significantly increase the accountant's time investment.

2. MYOB

MYOB is an established alternative offering comparable functionality including bank feeds and GST reporting through products like MYOB Essentials and MYOB Business — potentially at reduced cost compared to Xero Ignite.

3. Prosaic

Prosaic delivers a modern, AI-powered alternative specifically designed for the use cases Xero Cashbook served:

  • Live bank feed connectivity via open banking
  • AI-assisted transaction pre-coding for GST and year-end processes
  • Real-time reporting with client approval workflows
  • Bulk processing capabilities for high-volume clients
  • Intuitive interface designed for accountants managing multiple clients

Pricing starts at $5/month per client — significantly below both Xero Cashbook and the new Ignite plan — with scalable options for firms of all sizes.

Comparing the options

| | Xero Cashbook (retiring) | MYOB | Prosaic | | -------------------- | ------------------------ | ------- | ------------------ | | GST Cashbook | $28/month | Varies | $5/month | | Bank feeds | Yes | Yes | Yes (open banking) | | AI categorisation | No | Limited | Yes | | Home office expenses | No | No | Yes | | Client portal | No | Limited | Yes |

Conclusion

As Xero discontinues its GST Cashbook, accounting professionals must identify solutions balancing functionality with cost-effectiveness. Whether selecting manual spreadsheet systems, transitioning to MYOB, or adopting newer AI-powered tools like Prosaic, the objective remains delivering streamlined services without absorbing Xero's premium Ignite pricing.

Learn more about Prosaic for accountants and how it can replace Xero Cashbook at a fraction of the cost.